Header Overlay

Creating a World-Class Candidate Experience 

By Jennifer Silvester

Attracting top-tier executive talent in the rapidly evolving and competitive landscape of today’s labor market has transformed into a formidable challenge. Consequently, forward-thinking companies are revisiting and revamping their hiring strategies, putting a spotlight on a positive, candidate-centric approach as a key to enticing and retaining the best possible talent. In this piece, we’ll venture into the art and science of crafting an exceptional candidate experience—one that not only resonates with potential hires but also nurtures meaningful relationships for a long-lasting professional bond.

A black background with a white circle in the middle.

The Significance of the Candidate Experience:

Research from McKinsey reveals that a data-driven hiring approach, including enhancing the candidate experience, leads to a 40% increase in the quality of hires and a 12% decrease in attrition after one year. A report by PwC adds that 86% of job seekers research a company’s reviews before applying, and 56% of candidates would actively discourage others from applying if they had a poor candidate experience. By focusing on effective communication, providing insights into company culture, offering frequent feedback, keeping candidates engaged, and cultivating long-term relationships, you can strengthen your reputation as an employer and ensure you attract top-tier talent.

Throughout our entire executive hiring process, we try to maintain continuous engagement with our candidates. We recognize at S&C, that open lines of communication, ongoing support, and a personalized approach are instrumental to the candidate’s experience. By providing candidates with multiple touchpoints, ensuring they have opportunities to ask questions, seek guidance, and receive the necessary resources to make informed decisions, we demonstrate our commitment to their success and well-being. We focus on forging lasting relationships built on trust so we might be viewed as partners in our candidate’s professional journeys.

To improve the candidate experience in your organization, or to evaluate partners who represent your company in the hiring process, consider these strategies:


A black background with a white circle in the middle.

1. Build Relationships, Not Just Evaluate Candidates  
Build genuine relationships with candidates that go beyond merely evaluating their abilities. At S&C, we view interviews as opportunities to connect with candidates, understanding their aspirations, goals, and values. By establishing meaningful conversations, you enable candidates to showcase their skills and experiences while gathering insights into the potential client/company fit. Even if they’re not a candidate for a current role, note which opportunities might be better aligned for them in the future. By actively listening and showing genuine interest, you create a welcoming and inclusive environment that encourages candidates to open up and showcase their true potential.

A black background with a white circle in the middle.

2. Master the Art of Storytelling  
Paint a vivid picture of what it’s like to work at your/your client’s company. Doing so will empower candidates to make informed decisions and assess their own compatibility with the organizational culture. Organizations that prioritize sharing insights into company culture see tangible benefits in terms of employee engagement and retention. By providing candidates with a comprehensive understanding of the company’s culture, you increase the likelihood of attracting individuals who align with your values and contribute positively to the overall work environment, saving multiples on the investment of a wrong hire.

By harnessing the art of storytelling, your recruiters can effectively engage candidates, leave a lasting impression, and attract the right talent to their organizations. This transparency and alignment of values fosters stronger connections between candidates and clients and is a great indicator of their potential fit.

3. Clear and Frequent Communication 
Regular updates on the status of the hiring process are crucial for a positive candidate experience, especially at the C-suite level but really anyone who invests the time in an interview deserves to receive feedback. Whether it’s acknowledging the receipt of their application, providing updates on the progress, or informing them about next steps, timely communication shows that their candidacy is valued. Provide candidates with multiple touchpoints, ensure they have opportunities to ask questions, seek guidance, and receive the necessary resources to make informed decisions. Timelines often shift and a client’s best intentions are thwarted by other priorities or difficult schedules. At S&C, we do our best to clearly communicate timelines, expectations, and any changes in the process that helps candidates stay engaged and informed.

4. Providing Tangible FeedbackA black background with a white circle in the middle.
Offering candidates tangible, constructive feedback is crucial for their growth and development, as well as enhancing the candidate experience. By providing specific and constructive feedback, you show candidates that their time and effort are valued, even if they are not selected for the position. This feedback not only helps candidates understand areas for improvement but also strengthens their perception of your organization as professional and invested in their success.

5. Partnering with an Executive Search Firm

Consider working with a reputable executive search firm, like ours, who specializes in your industry. These firms have the expertise, time, and resources to create an exceptional candidate experience. According to PwC, businesses benefit from partnering with an executive search firm that can help them improve the candidate experience and implement strong recruitment strategies to attract and secure top talent.

A black background with a white circle in the middle.

In a competitive talent market, a world-class candidate experience is vital for executive search firms and companies seeking top-tier talent. By focusing on effective communication, providing insights into company culture, offering tangible feedback, and keeping candidates engaged, you can enhance the candidate experience and strengthen your employer brand. Partnering with an executive search firm can further elevate the candidate’s experience, ensuring a seamless and positive hiring process. By prioritizing the candidate’s experience, you not only attract the best talent but also cultivate long-term relationships and enhance your reputation as an employer of choice.